SHOULD I INSTALL FIBERGLASS SHINGLES OR UPGRADE TO METAL ROOFING?
Roof replacement projects in Arlington Heights, IL, can be stressful for Midwest homeowners, especially if those same homeowners are confused about what type of roofing material suits them best. Oftentimes homeowners are left comparing metal roofing over the more common fiberglass shingles.
Will the premium price of metal roofing or rubber roofing products be worth it in the end?
And how long can you expect a typical fiberglass roof to last?
You are wise to ask these questions and find out all of your options, resulting in the very best roof for your home and family.
Check out the below pros and cons of high quality fiberglass shingles and consider the added expense of metal roofing before making your final decision, and, as always, give Revived Exteriors a shout if you’re stuck on what to do next — we’re here to help!
Fiberglass Shingles: The Pros and Cons
If you are having your roof replaced in the warmer months of spring, summer, and autumn, the benefits of fiberglass asphalt shingles have a chance to shine.
Manufacturers used to make asphalt shingles from organic materials such as waste paper and fibers. This allowed for greater flexibility during the cold winter months but resulted in a shorter product lifespan and more problems with roof leaks. Today, most roofing jobs are completed using fiberglass asphalt shingles, made from inorganic materials that can easily withstand Father Time and the rougher elements with ease.
Fiberglass Shingles Colors
Fiberglass shingles come in a wide range of colors and profiles, with many mimicking the classic looks of clay tile or slate. Plenty of homebuilders use fiberglass shingles because of the affordable costs and attractive appearance, as well as the relatively quick installation and ease of roof repairs.
However, fiberglass roofing shingles will rot or fall apart over time, whereas a metal roof provides a lifetime of dependability in any climate, eliminating the need to replace your roof after ten or fifteen years.
If you are planning on remaining in your home for at least a few decades, you should plan on replacing your asphalt shingles at least twice, or possibly more, especially if heavy storms persist. Some fiberglass shingle manufacturers partner with expert roofing contractors and allow them to pass along better shingle and installation warranties. This option does cost a bit more but will pay off in the long run when the product is not pro-rated at a lesser amount each year. Meaning if your shingles fail before the warranty expires, they can be replaced at a full dollar amount versus a lesser amount due to depreciation.
Fiberglass Shingles Brands
Selecting the right shingles can exponentially increase the value and curb appeal of your home, so it’s not something you want to decide on a whim. Thankfully, there are plenty of options out there to choose from when it comes to high-quality, first-rate brands in the fiberglass shingle market.
GAF, Atlas, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed are just a few of the names that offer superior materials for your everyday roofing needs. As a leading roofing manufacturer in North America, GAF in particular offers unparalleled products and services to the average consumer and is one of the top-tier organic asphalt and fiberglass shingle manufacturers out there.
As a GAF-certified contractor, Revived Exteriors would be more than happy to help you on your next roofing journey. Sourcing our materials only from the best, our team will make sure your roof stands the test of time – and looks good doing so. Contact us today to find out more!
Metal Roofing: The Pros and Cons
While metal roofing certainly has its own advantages, it still falls short of what fiberglass shingles can provide.
Metal roofing does cost a significant amount more than fiberglass shingles. Material prices are higher, and this product requires special installation procedures and fasteners, pushing the cost even higher. This typically requires more oversight during the installation of the metal roofing product by a quality control specialist.
Depending on the age of your home and the size and pitch of your roof, some metal roofing may demand additional support. Most modern products are designed to be lightweight and efficient, but it is wise to have a professional roofer assess the project before investing in metal roofing materials.
The premium price of metal roofing improves the value of your home, although not enough to offset the initial investment. You need to value the product performance and plan to live with the assurance of metal’s dependability for years in order to fully appreciate the return on investment.
Metal Roofing Colors
Like fiberglass shingles, metal roofing comes in its own range of colors as well. They can run the gamut from polar white, forest green, cocoa brown, barn red, all the way to the pitch dark of midnight black. You’ll most likely see them on commercial buildings, but they have become more and more popular in gracing residential properties in recent years. Due to this, their options for colors have thus expanded, letting both business owners and homeowners design their roofs according to their aesthetics.
While you may be more familiar with corrugated and standing seam metal roofs – if not their name then certainly their paneled appearance – you may be surprised to learn that the shingles you’ve noticed in your neighborhood may be metal instead of traditional organic asphalt! With plenty of customization options, metal shingles can finely blur the line when it comes to the appearance of classic shingles, though their durability and longevity are unmatched compared to contemporary organic asphalt shingles.
Fiberglass Shingle Availability
Q: Do they still make fiberglass shingles?
A: Because most asphalt shingles manufactured today have a fiberglass mat, they are indeed still in production and can be found throughout the nation’s neighborhoods on all types of properties. They are a popular choice for many homeowners, young and old alike, thanks to their durability, flexibility in color and design, and cost-effectiveness.
Life Expectancy of Fiberglass Shingles
Q: How long do fiberglass shingles last?
A: They have a longer lifespan than some of their more basic counterparts, usually lasting up to 30 years with proper care and management. With premium quality materials and installation, some can even last up to 50 years.
Shingle Quality
Q: Are fiberglass shingles any good?
A: Very much so! These shingles can be found on homes in a variety of different climates, and can handle the highs and lows of extreme temperatures without becoming brittle or compromised like regular asphalt shingles.
Fiberglass vs Asphalt Shingles
Q: Are fiberglass shingles more expensive than asphalt shingles?
A: While both asphalt shingles and fiberglass shingles are manufactured using asphalt, they vary in their durability, design (architectural vs. 3-tab), resistance to fire and weather, and – most notably – their cost. While the final installation cost may differ state-to-state and from contractor to contractor, basic asphalt shingles will typically cost you between $3 and $6 per square foot, while basic fiberglass shingles can start at $3 per square foot and can go up to $9 per square foot if you’re looking for something more high-class.
Metal Roof Availability
Q: Do they still make metal shingles?
A: Metal shingles go as far back as the 19th century when shingles made out of tin were installed to protect a home’s denizens. Even now, they’re in wide circulation and can be seen in most average American neighborhoods. Though pricier than the average roofing material, they more than make up for it when it comes to how durable and resistant they are. They look great and sleek, too!
Life Expectancy of Metal Shingles
Q: How long do metal shingles last?
A: Metal can last 40 to 70 years, depending on the material (steel, aluminum, copper, etc.) used, the level of care put in during the installation process, and how well it is maintained throughout the years.
Shingle Quality
Q: Are metal shingles any good?
A: Metal shingles are some of the more high-quality, premium materials available on the market. Not all are created equal, though – for example, steel is appropriate for most climates, but aluminum or copper will be better choices for environments along the coast, due to their resistant nature against corrosive elements such as saltwater. Always discuss your options with a trusted roofing company to find the best solution for your property’s climate!
Metal vs Asphalt Shingles
Q: Are metal shingles more expensive than asphalt shingles?
A: Yes. Due to its many advantages over its asphalted neighbor, metal roofing, in particular, can be expensive. Most metal roof materials can cost between $1 to $25 per square foot, and, on average, a metal roof can set you back around $13,200. All of these are dependent on the size of your home, the quality of materials used, and the level of professionalism and experience of the hired roofing contractor who will be working with it.
Trust Arlington Heights’ Leading Experts in Fiberglass Shingles Today
Many homeowners are leaning toward the benefits of metal roofing, but the popularity of fiberglass shingles continues to hold out. Affordable, reliable, and easy to repair after storms or damage, fiberglass shingles remain a top choice for Midwest roofing projects.
If you’re ready to make the call on your next project, contact Revived Exteriors to learn more. With decades of experience under our belt, our contractors are ready to drive out to your area for a free consultation and get started on your dream roof today.